How to Choose the Right Material for Your Custom Card Decks

Material Options Overview

When it comes to custom playing cards, the material typically falls into one of the following types:

1. Standard paper‑stock cards—Traditional card stock (plain or coated), often used for mass promo decks, event giveaways, or short‑term usage. These are cost‑effective and ideal when you prioritize volume over longevity, making them a smart choice for bulk branding, promotional giveaways, or one‑time events. Due to their low cost, paper cards are perfect for businesses that need to distribute large quantities without compromising too much on design quality.

   • Paper + coating/film cards—Paper core with an extra finish (laminate, UV, foil), which improves durability and print effect. The additional layers help protect the design, enhance the gloss or matte appearance, and upgrade the tactile experience without the full cost of pure plastic. These cards combine the affordability of paper with the added protection of coatings, making them ideal for branded cards that need to withstand moderate wear and tear.

   • 100% plastic cards (PVC, PET, etc.)—fully plastic decks designed for repeated use, higher‑end applications, and premium branding. Built for durability, they resist moisture, bending, and heavy use, offering a long‑term investment for brands looking to elevate their card products. Plastic cards are especially suited for high-end games, luxury gifts, or professional settings where longevity and premium quality are essential. They are perfect for businesses that want to make a lasting impression with their products.

Here’s a quick comparison table:

According to research by COPAG, 100% plastic cards can last up to 50 times longer than paper decks. See more on our custom page.

Pros & Cons of Plastic Cards Advantages

• Extremely durable: They resist bending, tearing, water damage and frequent handling. 

• Easy to clean and maintain: Because plastic doesn’t absorb liquids in the same way, even spills can be wiped. For brands, that means the deck will remain in “mint condition” for longer. 

• High‑end feel and brand perception: A fully plastic deck conveys quality and professionalism—perfect for premium gifts, branded game cards, or luxury promotional decks.

• Better for repeated use/harsh conditions: IPlastic decks perform particularly well in venues (like casinos), outdoor settings, or any scenario where cards get heavy use.

Disadvantages

• Higher cost: Plastic playing cards tend to be significantly more expensive to manufacture than paper cards due to material cost and tooling/printing requirements.

• Feel/handling differences: Some users find plastic cards too slick or “slippery,” which can make shuffling or fanning feel less familiar.

• Brand/eco perception: For eco-conscious clients, plastic may be perceived as less sustainable compared to paper decks, especially if recyclability is limited.

• Less suitable for certain cardistry/magic uses: While plastic is durable, it may not “spring” or bend in the same way high-quality paper or linen-finish cards do, limiting its appeal among magicians or cardists.

• 

Pros & Cons of Paper Cards

Advantages

• Lower cost: Paper cards are more affordable than plastic, making them an ideal choice for budget‑friendly projects, large‑volume giveaways, or short‑term use. If you're looking to order a high quantity with minimal upfront investment, paper is often the way to go.

• Flexibility in print and finishing: Paper stock allows for a variety of custom finishes, such as foil stamping, UV spot, embossing, and lamination, which can enhance the overall design without significantly increasing production costs. These finishes are often easier and more cost‑effective to apply to paper cards compared to plastic.

• Preferred feel: For games like poker, cardistry, and magic tricks, many users prefer the classic, tactile feel of premium paper cards. These cards offer a better “bend” and are often more suitable for cardists and magicians due to their flexibility.

Disadvantages

• Shorter lifespan: Paper cards wear out faster than plastic, with edges fraying, bending, and moisture causing damage. For repeated use, paper cards may not last long.

  • Lower durability: Heavy use or rough handling can cause paper cards to lose shape and structure more quickly than plastic. For long-term durability, paper may not be the best choice.

  • Less premium positioning: Paper cards are seen as less durable and luxurious than plastic, which can impact their appeal for high-end or luxury products. For premium use, plastic may be the better option.

  • 

How to Choose Based on Your Project

Choosing the right material for your custom playing cards depends on your project's goals. Here are some typical scenarios and material recommendations:

• Long-term brand gift or premium card game: Choose plastic (or high-end coated paper) for superior durability, longevity, and a high-end feel. These materials not only enhance your brand value but also ensure your deck remains in pristine condition over time, ideal for luxury giveaways or premium games.

• One-time event giveaway or large-volume promotional deck: Paper is a highly cost-effective choice for short-term use, large runs, and one-time giveaways. It’s perfect for events where cards won’t be subject to frequent handling, allowing you to save on material costs while still providing a professional design.

• Tabletop game with frequent play and shipping: Plastic is ideal for heavy use, frequent shuffling, or shipping to customers. Plastic cards are durable and hold up well over time. Paper cards can be a suitable alternative for moderate use, offering a balance of quality and affordability.

• Eco-conscious brand: Consider FSC-certified or recycled paper to align with your brand’s commitment to sustainability and environmental responsibility. These options are not only eco-friendly but also maintain excellent print quality.

• Budget-restricted order (e.g., 5,000+ units): Paper is perfect for bulk orders where material cost is a key consideration. You can still create a premium feel through creative designs and finishing touches like UV coating, foil stamping, or embossing.

• 

Key Considerations When Choosing Material

When selecting the material for your custom playing cards, consider these five key factors:

1. Durability & Lifespan
   How long do you expect the cards to last? Plastic cards offer extended durability, ideal for high-frequency use, while paper cards are better for short-term or one-time events.

2. User Experience & Feel
   How do the cards feel when shuffled and held? Plastic cards are smoother and more slippery, perfect for premium games, while paper cards offer more grip, ideal for cardistry or magic tricks.

3. Print & Finishing Compatibility
   Which material suits your design? Paper cards are often better for intricate prints and finishes like foil, UV spot, and embossing, while plastic cards support high-quality prints but may require specialized techniques.

4. Cost vs Value
   Consider both upfront costs and long-term value. Plastic cards may have a higher upfront cost but deliver greater long-term value due to their durability. Paper cards are budget-friendly initially but may need replacement over time.

5. Brand & Environmental Alignment
   Does the material align with your brand's values? Plastic may be suited for luxury or high-end branding, while recycled paper is perfect for eco-conscious brands looking to showcase sustainability.

Conclusion 

Choosing the right material for your custom playing cards depends on your project’s specific needs. Plastic is perfect for premium, long-term products that require durability and a high-end feel, while paper is a cost-effective choice for short-term giveaways, large volumes, or promotional decks. Understanding your goals, whether it's luxury branding or a one-time event, will help guide your material selection.

💡 Next Step: Contact our team at IVAPOKER for sample decks, and compare the feel, finishes, and durability of both plastic and paper materials. We’ll work with you to provide a tailored quote and ensure your cards meet your design and brand needs. Let’s make your custom cards a reality!

FAQs

Q: If I’m ordering 500 decks for a brand giveaway, should I go plastic or paper?
A: For a one‑time giveaway, paper is likely the most cost‑effective. Unless you plan for recipients to reuse the decks long‑term, plastic may over‑invest.

Q: How much more expensive is plastic compared to paper?
A: It depends on stock, tooling and finishing, but industry data suggests plastic can cost significantly more upfront. The higher cost is offset by longer lifespan and lower replacement frequency. Copag USA, Inc.

Q: My brand cares about sustainability—what should I use?
A: Choose FSC‑certified or recycled paper stock, and highlight that in your messaging. Alternatively, if you use plastic, you may emphasize “reuse many times” as a sustainability benefit.

Q: Can I request samples of both materials?
A: Yes—most OEM manufacturers will provide sample decks of both paper and plastic variants. Testing feel, shuffle and durability helps you decide.

Q: What finishing options work for each material?
A: On paper, you have wide options: foil stamping, spot UV, embossing, lamination. On plastic, finishing is also possible but may cost more and require specialized tools. Choose finishes consistent with material.